You're currently browsing our buylist ← Return to Store

The "Buylist" page you are on is used to sell us your used cards.  As long as the "Buylist" button at the top of the page is outlined, you are looking at items we are wanting to buy. 

If you type the name of a card in the search bar at the top, you'll see results for items we want. Each item will have the quantity we're willing to buy and the price we will pay for a Near mint copy of it (20% bonus in store credit instead of check)

We no longer accept buy orders that are shipped to us.  All buy orders must be dropped off in person (after online approval).  This is to help prevent fraud and other problems with shipping.  We apologize for any inconvenience.

Please Read these Buylist Instructions describing how to sell cards to us.

Also take a look at our Grading Guide


Sell Bulk Rares/Mythics!

If cards are not on our buylist (usually worth under $.50 each), you can sell rares and mythics in Light play or better condition to us in bulk.  Rares pay 10 cents and mythics 25 cents cash, or 20% more in store credit.

Limit of 8 copies per card please.


Bulk Grading Options

For the time being, we are not accepting bulk buy orders.  You may still sell us large orders through the buylist website and use the Bulk Rare and Bulk Mythic items, however we are not doing bulk grading due to staffing.  

If you wish to donate bulk Magic or Pokemon cards, we gladly accept and appreciate your donations.  They go towards building beginner-player packs and door prizes for our kids' events.


If you don't want to go through your collection card by card to list them, you can have us evaluate it.  We charge $15/hour labor, which roughly translates to about 1000 cards if they're in decent order.  Less organized cards will take us longer (cards jumbled, upside down, facing wrong direction, etc.).  After we estimate the value of the collection, we will offer a price, which we will pay in cash or store credit.  If you accept, the evaluation fee will be waived.

Tweets by @BHGames